This Firebrand Brief started with the latest German bishops’ controversy, but it quickly became something bigger: a blunt, practical talk about trust, obedience, Catholic media noise, and why ordinary Catholics should stop letting every headline and every online panic merchant rob them of peace.
Segment 1: Germany, Lay Homilies, and the Latest Round of Catholic Panic
I open the episode with the Vatican rejecting a request from the German Bishops’ Conference to allow lay faithful to preach the homily during Mass in exceptional circumstances. I explain why lay people cannot preach the homily, why Germany keeps becoming the center of these strange Catholic controversies, and why every new headline out of Germany becomes fuel for distrust.
But the larger point is not simply “Germany is weird.” The larger point is that Catholics are being trained to treat every clerical controversy as proof that the Church herself cannot be trusted.
- The Vatican said no to the German request.
- Lay people are not permitted to preach the homily at Mass.
- Germany’s recent controversies are being used by some Catholics as evidence against trust in the Church.
- The problem is not noticing foolishness. The problem is letting foolishness form your relationship to the Church.
“There’s always going to be bozos in the Church. So what?”
Segment 2: Accept Everything. Toss Away What Doesn’t Matter.
The heart of the episode is my rule for Catholic trust: accept everything and toss away what doesn’t matter. That does not mean Catholics should become mindless or passive. It means we should begin from trust, docility, and obedience rather than suspicion, defiance, and rage.
Not everything a bishop, cardinal, priest, or Catholic media personality says carries the same weight. Some things belong to the Magisterium and must be received seriously. Other things are just noise. The problem is that many Catholics have been conditioned to throw everything into the same basket and view it all with the same suspicion.
I use the co-redemptrix controversy and Pope Francis as examples of how Catholics often reject something not because it is false, but because it sounds unfamiliar.
- Catholics need to distinguish actual teaching from clerical noise.
- The ordinary Magisterium deserves docility, not instant suspicion.
- An active mind is dangerous when the will has not learned obedience.
- Some things that sound strange are not wrong; they may simply be unfamiliar Catholic theology.
“Accept everything and ignore what doesn’t matter.”
Segment 3: Catholic Media, Lost Peace, and the Need for a News Blackout
The final major movement of the episode turns toward Catholic media itself. I argue that many Catholics have lost their peace because they have spent years ingesting outrage, suspicion, and rage-bait from independent Catholic media. The result is not holiness. It is anxiety, anger, and distrust.
A listener in the chat says she stopped watching several Catholic YouTubers because she had lost her way and lost her peace. That becomes a key moment in the episode. I connect it to my own experience with secular news blackouts and argue that Catholics may need the same thing with Catholic media.
The advice is simple: practice the faith, stop feeding on constant noise, and let God deal with the bozos.
- Constant Catholic media consumption can magnify anxiety because Catholics care deeply about the Church.
- Rage-based media does not just inform; it forms.
- News blackouts can restore peace.
- Catholics should pray for evangelizers, including the troubled, the dangerous, and the faithful ones trying to do good work.
“Practice the Catholic faith and let God sort out the bozos.”
Full Episode
Watch or listen to the full episode here 👇 It includes links to YouTube, Spotify, Apple, etc
TJ Haines
Visit TheForge.fm for Catholic commentary on news, culture, faith, and formation.
Stay dangerous.
Member discussion